Today
🔥 0-day streak◎ Today 0/1 task⚓ 0 nautical miles
Everyday Wisdom · Mind & Decisions · Lesson 5/12 · about 4 min
Hanoi's 1902 rat-tail bounty: a lesson in incentives
Mind & Decisions
To get people to do the right thing: keep reminding them, or fix how they are rewarded?
The answer in one sentence: People respond very strongly to how they are rewarded and punished; to change behaviour, look at the reward system before blaming attitudes, and always ask 'what is this system accidentally rewarding?'.
1Guess first
In 1902, fearing that rats in the new sewer system would spread plague, Hanoi's French colonial government paid 1 cent for every rat killed. To claim it, you only had to hand in the tail. What happened?
Officials began noticing tailless rats running around the city. People cut off the tails and let the rats go back into the sewers to breed; some sources also report rats being farmed for their tails. The scheme was scrapped. Nobody was 'bad': they did exactly what they were paid for.
2Explained in 3 steps
You get what you reward
The Hanoi scheme paid for tails, not for fewer rats. People optimise exactly what is measured and paid for. This is a general rule: once a number becomes the basis for rewards and punishments, people will push that number up, even if the real goal is forgotten.
Munger put incentives first
In his famous talk on the psychology of human misjudgment, Charlie Munger, Warren Buffett's long-time partner, put the tendency to respond to rewards and punishments at the top of his list. The line often attributed to him: 'Show me the incentive and I will show you the outcome.'
Incentives bend thinking too
Incentives don't only change behaviour; they change how people see things. A salesperson on commission sincerely believes their product is the best; someone paid by the hour sincerely feels the job needs more time. Most of them aren't lying; they are being steered by their incentives.
Picture it: It's like a navigation app set to a single goal, 'shortest distance': it will route you through narrow alleys and flooded streets, because that's the only thing you rewarded.
3Use it today
- When someone does something puzzling, first ask: 'How is this person rewarded or punished?' before concluding they are incompetent or bad.
- When you get advice on insurance, investments or a big purchase, ask the adviser directly how they are paid. Not to distrust them, but to know which way the advice leans.
- When assigning work or setting targets, ask: 'Could someone hit this number while the real goal still fails?' If so, change the measure or add a second one to keep it honest.
- For yourself: to drop a bad habit, make it harder to do and reward the good habit right away, instead of relying on willpower alone.
4Common misconceptions
Myth: People get things wrong because they don't care; remind them enough and it will be fine.
Actually: Reminders are far weaker than the bonuses, fines, praise and criticism people face every day. Fixing the system usually works better than fixing the people.
Myth: An adviser on commission must be cheating me.
Actually: Most of them genuinely believe what they say; incentives distort judgment unconsciously. Knowing that helps you double-check, not accuse.
5One Chinese word to take home
激励
jīlì · Sino-Vietnamese: khích lệ · incentive, motivation
In Vietnamese, khích lệ means to encourage. In management, Chinese says 激励机制 (jīlì jīzhì), an 'incentive mechanism': how rewards and penalties are set up.
6Three quick questions
1. Why did Hanoi's rat-tail bounty fail?
Answer: It paid for tails, not for fewer rats. People optimised exactly what they were paid for: tails.
2. According to Munger, what should you check first to change a group's behaviour?
Answer: The reward and punishment system. He put the power of rewards and punishments at the top of his list.
3. Staff get a bonus per customer-care call. What is the most obvious risk?
Answer: Lots of short, shallow calls to hit the number. Paying for the number of calls gets you calls, not necessarily happy customers.
Progress is saved on this device. No account needed.