Today
🔥 0-day streak◎ Today 0/1 task⚓ 0 nautical miles
Everyday Wisdom · Mind & Decisions · Lesson 6/12 · about 5 min
Inversion: first ask 'how would this fail?'
Mind & Decisions
Want to stay healthy: hunt for secrets, or list what is sure to make you ill?
The answer in one sentence: Many problems get easier when turned upside down: instead of asking 'how do I succeed?', ask 'what would surely make this fail?' and avoid each item; before a project, imagine it has already failed to find the reasons early.
1Guess first
One group is told: 'Imagine the project has failed badly. Why?' Another is asked: 'What risks might the project face?' Which group comes up with more reasons?
Treating the outcome as if it had already happened helps people come up with more reasons (one 1989 study found about 30% more). That is the basis of the pre-mortem technique popularised by psychologist Gary Klein.
2Explained in 3 steps
Turn the question around
Munger liked to borrow a line from the mathematician Carl Jacobi: 'Invert, always invert.' His famous joke: 'All I want to know is where I'm going to die, so I'll never go there.' The question 'how can I be happy?' is vague; 'what would surely make me miserable?' gives you a concrete list straight away. Munger himself once listed some 'prescriptions for guaranteed misery': taking mood-altering chemicals, envy, resentment, being unreliable.
Avoid stupidity first, be clever second
Munger argued that he and Buffett gained much of their long-term advantage by consistently trying not to be stupid, rather than trying to be very intelligent. Dropping one destructive habit is often worth more than learning one more clever trick.
The pre-mortem
Before starting something big, the team imagines: 'A year from now, this has failed badly.' Everyone writes down the reasons for a few minutes, then reads them out in turn. It gives people who hesitate to contradict the boss a safe excuse to raise risks, and the team deals with the risks before they happen.
Picture it: Like a captain planning a voyage: not just drawing the route to port, but first marking the shoals, reefs and storm zones. Know where you would surely run aground and the safe route reveals itself.
3Use it today
- Pick one of your goals (health, money, work), write down 5 ways that would surely make it fail, then mark the ones you are already doing without realising.
- Before a project or a big expense, spend 10 minutes on a pre-mortem: everyone writes down reasons for failure before the group discussion starts.
- When you're stuck on 'how do I make this better?', switch to 'how would I make it worse?', then do the opposite.
4Common misconceptions
Myth: Inversion is pessimism: only seeing the bad.
Actually: The point is to avoid the bad in order to reach the good. Even the most optimistic captain needs to know where the shoals are.
Myth: Asking 'what are the risks?' is the same as imagining 'it has failed'.
Actually: They differ: once failure is treated as a fact, people hold back less and come up with more concrete reasons.
5One Chinese word to take home
逆向思维
nìxiàng sīwéi · Sino-Vietnamese: nghịch hướng tư duy · inversion, thinking backwards
逆 means against the flow, as in 逆境 (adversity); 向 is direction; 思维 is thinking.
6Three quick questions
1. Which question shows inversion?
Answer: What would surely make me poorer, and which of those am I doing?. Inversion looks for what surely leads to failure, in order to avoid it.
2. In a pre-mortem, what does the team imagine?
Answer: The project has failed badly, and then they look for reasons. Treating failure as already happened helps find more concrete reasons.
3. According to Munger, where does long-term advantage often come from?
Answer: Consistently avoiding stupid mistakes. Persistently not doing stupid things is an underrated advantage.
Progress is saved on this device. No account needed.